Live vs. Photo (2)

These portraits are again from a photo and from a live sitting (the one on the left from a photo) of a friend who was visiting from Berlin. The one done from life is a better drawing capturing as it does a certain intelligence and characteristic expression of the sitter. However, as Mirka remarked (and she was right!) the drawing makes the width of her face too narrow.

Interestingly, it took me three tries to get close to a resemblance when working from the photo. Mirka’s face is asymmetrical ( actually all of our faces are, but some people are more asymmetrical than others), which I got in the sketch, but struggled with when using the photo. And again, as a drawing, the one done from the photo has an overworked quality which I don’t like.

I’m going to do one or two more drawings of Mirka, this time working from the drawings rather than the photo. Let’s see what happens!

Live vs. Photo

Many (most?) artists work with photos when they do portraits. The advantages are clear: the sitter is not forced into hours of boredom; the artist can draw and redraw the face in her own time; the hard work of going from 3D to 2D has been done by an apparatus. The problem, I find, however, is that there is a tendency for the portrait done in close dependence on a photo to often look “frozen”, stiff, and inhuman!

There is something in the drawing using stereoscopic vision with the breathing model in front of me, that captures the energy and reality of the living person better than a drawing done from a photo. The downside is that sometimes the resemblance slips away (and that can happen, maddeningly, with a slight mistake in the distance between the eyes or the length of the chin or the shape of an eyebrow!).

In previous centuries, the best artists could not only get a resemblance, but they also (amazingly) could retain the image of the person and repeat it from memory! However, part of this skill came about because artists redid work: redrew, repainted, reconceptualized the image, as can be seen in many Degas studies. I was not trained to do this, but I am going to be working this way for awhile to see what I can learn from it. The trick, I think, is to reverse engineer the image in the photo to recapture the vitality of the living model.

My friend Val was kind enough to sit for me recently for the drawings at the top of this post. I usually draw for about 1/2 an hour then take photos of my model. The drawing on the right was done from life; the one on the left from the photo I took during the same sitting. The drawings are, as always, watercolor pencil on paper.

The Daily Practice of Portraiture

Chris with Bonchat
‘Chris with Bonchat’ watercolor pencil on paper 11″ x 15″ © J.Hart

I am going to take a suggestion from Seth Godin and start a daily blog of my portraiture work. I am practicing doing portraits in order to become as skilled as possible so that I can work with live models as well as photos. Also, doing this practice in public will keep me honest and on task!

Today’s drawing is of my neighbor Chris with his very ironically named cat, Bonchat sitting on our balcony in late summer. This portrait got to the heart of their relationship: undemonstrative cat, very loving master!

Although I did this from a photo, I worked to get some of the more interesting and less definitive marks of unmediated seeing. It is also fun to do portraits of friends and family that I know well. The portrait is more likely to be an authentic representation of the person.

More on the difference between working from life and from photos tomorrow!

 

Drawing the live model

monotone-2-28-17I

It must look odd from the outside, this act of drawing a nude live model. But when one has done it one’s whole life, well at least since art school, as I have, it really seems very unexceptional.

I am doing these drawings of life classes as a way to think about where one sees naked bodies. Degas put his in bedrooms; Bonnard painted his wife in the bath; Lucien Freud just plopped his models down on dirty sheets or filthy floors. The old masters painted nudes in lovely landscapes or ensconced in luxurious beds…but there always was a context.

However, that context is nowhere to be seen in most nude drawings I see being made. Yet the idea that nudes are central to “real art” seems to be alive and well, if the packed class I attended today is any indication. But I’m not quite sure why people feel this way!

Il doit sembler étrange de l’extérieur, cet acte de dessin d’un modèle vivant nu. Mais quand on a fait sa vie entière, bien au moins depuis l’école d’art, comme je l’ai, il semble vraiment pas exceptionnel.

Je fais ces dessins de classes de vie comme un moyen de penser où l’on voit des corps nus. Degas a mis son dans les chambres; Bonnard peignit sa femme dans le bain; Lucien Freud vient de déposer ses modèles sur des draps sales ou des planchers sales. Les anciens maîtres peignaient des nus dans de beaux paysages ou se cachaient dans des lits luxueux … mais il y avait toujours un contexte.

Cependant, ce contexte est nul par être vu dans la plupart des dessins nus que je vois être fait. Pourtant, l’idée que les nus sont au centre de «l’art réel» semble être en vie et bien, si la classe emballée que j’ai assistée aujourd’hui est une indication. Mais je ne sais pas très bien pourquoi les gens se sentent de cette façon!

A Painter’s Progress

Welcome to a new blog, “A Painter’s Progress,” a new website, JHart-Artist, and a New Year!

I made a few New Year’s resolutions that I would like to share with you:

  1. I would like to invite you to be a witness to my daily practice of painting. This blog is a great way for you to get a peek into what is involved in creating art. You will see and understand how I make art: what the struggles are, and what the pleasures. I will happily answer any of your questions about the process. It is also a good way for me to stay honest about what I do!
  2. I have also changed my art practice to be more collaborative. Like artists in the past, I must be responsive to the needs of my society. So, to a certain degree, my skills are in the service of my fans’ and patrons’ interests and passions. I can paint anything in any style, but I am interested in learning what you want to see in a painting. Your comments are important to me!
  3. And finally, I am building and running this blog & website myself. I had a great webmaster, Natalia Usselman, for my last website, but I found that having someone else set it up and run it let me off the hook. For the New Year, I am pulling up my big-girl panties and building and running http://www.jhart-artist.com myself. It will be, like all my other art pieces, a work in progress!

Hoping to hear from you soon!

In the meantime, I wish you and yours the happiest of holidays and a healthy and peaceful 2017!